I did mention I'm not as familiar with Ceremonial magic as I am other forms of magic. I am aware that the Kabblah/Quabblah is a large part of Ceremonial magic or rather some forms of ceremonial magic.I just didn't know enough about it to really explain or expand on it as part of my definition/explanation of ceremonial magic. That's why I said "as I understand them". I know I have a lot to learn in that regards. I did figure that I had at least a basic concept of the differences.random417 wrote:@ loona As a CM practitioner myself, I'd consider your definition to be pretty accurate, with the exception of one thing... kabbalah is very much a Ceremonial practice, and pathworkings and astral travel to the sepheroth is a almost essential part of that. Mind you, not every ceremonialist works kabbalah, and not every (magickal) kabbalist does the astral travel stuff, but imho, everyone that does kabbalah seriously should.
I think you should start a thread on the Kabblah/Quabblah. There is a lot that it covers and its really beyond the scope of this thread. Needless to say I think that it would be an interesting topic here.
I've always understood it to be one of the tree of lifes or a map of the universe and multi-verse both for the body and for spiritual travel and work. How those play together I have never really been able to follow. If I manage to return to my training in the Temple tradition I will learn about it and how its been worked into witchcraft. The 4th degree of the Temple tradition is based on the Quabblah. So I have a ways to go before I learn that lol
I would say that Thelema is also an exception to this. I don't think Thelema works within that mindset and philosophical world view. At least not as I have interpreted the book of the Law and other Thelemic writings. The Golden Dawn though is very much a Christian Organization.random417 wrote:I would say that ceremonial magick is inherently monotheistic, but I would say that the core beliefs are closer to Jewish beliefs than Christian. (There are exceptions to this, the Rosicrucians for example).
I never argued that Ceremonial magic was monothesitic. I've always experienced it within the concepts of a Christian mindset and frame of reference. This is why I approcah the concepts of ceremonial magic with that view. In many places its easier to consider ceremonial magic Christian Mysticim and the Quabblah as Jewish Mysticism as there are people who believe the two practices should be studied seperatly due to different cultures.
I think for those who engage with the Quabblah it might be better to think of it in terms of Abrahamic mysticism. That covers the elements from Christianity and the elements from Jewish Mysticism. I dont know much if anything about Islam or any of the mystical practices that may be related there. I'm sure they have some sort of mysticism.
So I sort of saw them as related fields yet separate. Does that make sense? I can see how they may be worked together but I also see how they are seperate systems.
Can you expand on this a bit?random417 wrote:I would argue that underneath the veneer however, the beliefs attempt to transcend Abrahamic faiths... in the kabbalah for example, "God the Father" corresponds to Chessed, only about half way up the Tree of Life. Honestly, personally, that's below where the Wiccan concepts of God and Goddess lie on the Tree.
I love the quote from The Kyballion "The All is Mind, The Universe is Mental". I've gotten some good questions about that quote. I believe that this mind and this all is what makes up the force of magic. This is the ability to create and work. This is also why spells and rituals can be performed entirely in the mind and still be effective. I'm actually going to work on a book about how the Kyballion's philosophy applies practically to magical and spiritual work. I just need to develop the exercises (as in do the work I'm going to put as exercises in the text) before I do so,random417 wrote:I am also an animist, of a sort. Hermetic philosophy teaches "all is mind" and it's the "mind" that forms the spirit. A little different in detail, but when explaining to people, animism comes into play enough.