REVIEW: Goodrich's Guinevere

Review and recommend pagan, spiritual, Wicca, & witchcraft books.
Post Reply
User avatar
Heartsong
Posts: 1342
Joined: Tue Oct 01, 2013 2:07 pm
Gender: Female
Location: South Carolina

REVIEW: Goodrich's Guinevere

Post by Heartsong »

Guinevere by Norma Lorre Goodrich

As promised, here is the review for Guinevere. This volume is an intriguing look into the historical and literary role of King Arthur’s queen, Guinevere. Goodrich delves into both historical records and medieval texts in an attempt to reconstruct, and pardon, one of the most famous adulterers of all time. According to Goodrich, it was a combination of male fear and misunderstanding that ultimately led to Guinevere unjustly gaining this reputation. She argues that rather than the unfaithful, traitorous queen with which modern society has grown acquainted, Guinevere was in a fact one of the most powerful pagan priestesses of her time.

Goodrich begins her examination of Guinevere with where she supposedly died, stating that she had found her gravemarker in the highlands of Scotland, an ancient Pictish monument carved with images of the queen.

Image

She claims that :
If heroical epics had ever been written about women, heroines, of if epics had ever even portrayed a heroic woman, then that sort of biography would have suited Queen Guinevere.
Guinevere was not only a priestess, one that initiated Lancelot into her Mysteries and shared with an intimacy that transcended mere sexual union, she was also the true sovereign of Britain. Through her, Arthur gained a legitimate claim to the throne, and it is through her wisdom and guidance that his knights became world renowned. Goodrich examines the symbolism present in the legends and tales surrounding the queen, bringing them into the light and searching them for clues, tantalizing hints that could lead to the truth.

While Goodrich’s detective work is top notch, she pays minute attention to detail and is meticulous about scouring texts for information, she takes up huge chunks of the book in simply re-telling the tales. Massive portions that could have been devoted to more theory and explanation of that theory are instead used inefficiently as repetition of stories that one could easily read for oneself on the internet or in any bookstore. Also, some of her evidence is less than convincing, and I wondered if some of conclusions were simply pulled out of the ether. There is no supporting evidence, for example, to support her claim that Lancelot was ever a king of Scotland, other than her unverifiable word that his name translates from old French to “Angus”, the old Scottish Gaelic word for king.

What she has to say about Guinevere specifically, however, does somewhat make up for her conjectures, because it’s simply fascinating from a Pagan point of view to not only contemplate the possibility that she was, in fact, just such a thing, but also that she was falsely accused and her name marred by a fearful, patriarchal society and church.

Overall, I would give this text a 3.8 out of 5. What Goodrich has to say is interesting, but her lack of concrete evidence makes me skeptical. Still, a very engaging and absorbing read. :flyingwitch:
Dance like the Maiden
Laugh like the Mother
Think like the Crone
User avatar
Violet
Posts: 129
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2012 7:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Fort Worth, TX
Contact:

Re: REVIEW: Goodrich's Guinevere

Post by Violet »

This is really interesting to me. I always felt there was a great significance in the triad between herself, Lancelot and Arthur, and these legends would not have remained with us if they did not contain intrinsic truth, regardless of the facts. Does the book specify much about Guinevere's religious beliefs?
User avatar
Heartsong
Posts: 1342
Joined: Tue Oct 01, 2013 2:07 pm
Gender: Female
Location: South Carolina

Re: REVIEW: Goodrich's Guinevere

Post by Heartsong »

Goodrich doesn't really delve much further into Guinevere's beliefs other than to put forth the hypothesis that she was a high priestess of one of the older Pictish religions. She doesn't explain the religion itself at all, and that was one of the biggest issues I had with the book, and part of why I felt that her arguments were not as compelling as they could have been. To be honest, it almost seems like Goodrich was basing her interpretations of many of the stories on "generic" pagan practices, for lack of a better term (such as Lancelot's passage through the perilous castle in "Knight of the Cart", and subsequent knighting by Guinevere, being equated to an initiation).
Dance like the Maiden
Laugh like the Mother
Think like the Crone
Post Reply

Return to “Book Reviews”